You can show the court that he is not the owner and and is through the funds of your father
My father has bought land in 1976 in the name of my elder brother since I was minor during that time. Father has deposited money in elder brother's account for payment through cheque. In 1983 the ground and first floor was constructed over 60 percent of the land area and since then I had occupied first floor and my elder brother occupied ground floor. Now, my elder brother is claming ownership of land and has occupied the remaining land area. Request your views on how to get share on land.
Father had bought land in the name of elder brother for the benefit of joint family
2) in any case, brother was a minor at that time and no source of funds to purchase the set property
3) Brother cannot claim absolute ownership of the said land
4) You have to file a declaratory suit that you have equal share in the said land as brother had no source of funds to purchase the said land
Since the land was purchased in your elder brother’s name but paid for by your father, it may be considered a benami transaction under the Benami Transactions (Prohibition) Act, 1988 (applicable retrospectively). Here’s what you can do:
File a civil suit claiming your share based on your father’s financial contribution and your long-term possession.
Request the court to declare the land as joint family property and seek partition.
Gather bank records, cheque details, and any proof showing that the land was purchased using your father’s money.
Any family records or written communication acknowledging your share will strengthen the case.
If you can prove your father paid for the land and it was held in trust for the family, you can challenge your brother’s sole ownership under the Benami law.
File an injunction suit to stop your brother from occupying the remaining land until the dispute is resolved.
If possible, try to settle the matter through a family settlement agreement to avoid prolonged litigation.
Immediate Step: Gather evidence and file for partition & injunction. Let me know if you need help drafting the suit.
For detailed, personalized advice, consider a phone consultancy. Hope you find the information helpful. You are free to contact me for further discussion. If you could spare two minutes of your time to write a review, it would be greatly appreciated and bring immense happiness to read it. Thank you. Shubham Goyal.
As the property was purchased by your father on your brother's name, it becomes your brother's property hence any claim towards any share in the property made by you may not be tenable in law.
However if the property was purchased using ancestral funds (money inherited from previous generations), you may have a claim to a share, even if the property is in your brother's name.
If the property was purchased using your father's self-earned money, it is considered his self-acquired property, and he can legally transfer it to anyone, including your brother, without your consent.
You have not stated whether your father is living or not, if your father is living then you cannot claim any share in the property as right for any reason.
If your father had a will and it specifies the distribution of his property, the will will determine who inherits what.
If you can prove that your father used ancestral funds to purchase the property, you may have a stronger case for a share, even if the property is in your brother's name.
You may need to provide evidence such as bank statements, transaction records, or other documentation that demonstrates your father's financial contribution.
You cannot legally get a share of the property if it is registered in your brothers name. The law will consider that the property is owned by your brother.
Your brother is absolute owner of property even if consideration is paid by your father. The act of your father in making payment of consideration is barred and prohibited by Benami Transaction Act. Even you have never raised any objection after attaining majority. You donot have any right to claim any share nor you have any right in the property.
Thank you all for your response and it's much appreciated. My elder brother has used my father's money since he was supporting my father in his business and my father infused his own money to buy land. My elder brother did not used his own money and I understand burden to prove is on my brother to present docs evidecncig source of his income. Even if he is able to manage source of income, capital investment on brother's business was of my father and I didn't get the share of father's money during that time being I was minor. Request your further suggestion.
Act of your father in making payment of consideration is barred by benami transaction Act. On attaining majority you too have not raised your issue so any case would be barred. Otherwise also, you donot have any right in property. However, this issue us required to be tackled tactfully.
File declaratory suit that land was bought in brother name for benefit of joint family and that you have equal share in the land
Any property purchased out of joint family business is joint family. Such purchase can be in the name any coparcener brother, father or son.
A son has no rights over his father's money or earnings during the lifetime of his father hence whether you were a minor or major you cannot say that you were not given a share of money by your father then.
You have no rights over it and there is no force of law on your Father to give you any money therefore you may decide what to do next.
- If the said property is registered in the name of your brother then you have no right over the said property
- However, you can claim equal right over the property on the ground of purchasing the said property on family fund.
- You can file a Partition & Declaration suit before the Court for partition of the property on the ground that the property was purchased by father in the name of brother , and hence after demise of father you have equal right over the property.
I'm not sure, however I understand elder brother can't stop my way towards my home from his land and parking space as well which I was using since 40 years. Being having possession of 1st floor and terrace along with municipal Tax paid of my part since years, elder brother has to go through some huddles where 1st floor is occupied my myself and if he tries to sell entire land, the buyer may come into trouble.
You can file a suit for declaration on the basis of the documentary evidences in your possession and merits and also get an order of injunction to restrain him from alienating or interfering in your possession and enjoyment of the property.
Issue a lawyer's notice in local newspapers warning general pubic against entering into any transaction with brother as the property is joint. No will take risk of going ahead with such transaction.
Right of Easement (Access & Parking)
Since you have used the pathway and parking for 40 years, you have an easementary right under the Indian Easements Act, 1882.
Your brother cannot legally block your access to your home.
Strength of Your Possession
You have possession of the first floor & terrace for decades.
Paying municipal taxes further proves your legal interest in the property.
If Brother Tries to Sell the Land
Any sale will be difficult because you are an existing occupant.
A buyer must legally evict you, which will require a court order.
Your possession will discourage potential buyers from purchasing the disputed property.
Injunction Suit
File an injunction to stop your brother from selling or blocking access.
Partition Suit
If no settlement is possible, file for partition to claim your share.
Stay Order Against Sale
Get a court order preventing the sale of the property until the dispute is resolved.
Would you like help drafting the legal notice?
Will the act for possession of more than 12 years in private property helps ?
No, mere possession for 12 years neither take away right and entitlement of your brother nor mere possession or payment of tax confer any right. Your brother has no right to sell all properties without your consent and noc.
The law of adverse possession may not operate in your situation.
You may discuss with a local lawyer and proceed as suggested.
Adverse possession (12+ years of continuous, open, and hostile possession) can be claimed, but in your case, it may not be the best option because:
1️⃣ Family-Owned Property – Since you occupied the first floor with your brother’s knowledge, it’s not hostile possession, which is a key requirement for adverse possession.
2️⃣ Better Legal Options Exist – Instead of adverse possession, a partition suit based on your father’s financial contribution is a stronger claim.
3️⃣ Right of Easement – Since you've used the access and parking for 40 years, you can legally stop your brother from blocking your path under the Indian Easements Act, 1882.
✅ File a Partition Suit – Claim your rightful share based on your father’s payment.
✅ Get an Injunction – Stop your brother from blocking access or selling the land.
✅ Use Adverse Possession (Only If Needed) – As a backup if all else fails.
Would you like help drafting a legal notice or partition suit?