• Legal action against franchisee for business losses, fraud negligence, and data theft

Dear Kanoon.com Lawyers/Team,

I am seeking legal advice on pursuing action against a franchisee in, India, who has directly contributed to substantial financial losses for my UK-based business. The Hyderabad franchise was officially registered as a franchise and was responsible for back-office operations, including sales, marketing, customer support, payment collections, and managing critical customer data on behalf of the UK company.

Recently, the franchisee has become unresponsive, switching off their phones and seemingly absconding. In addition, they took important data (such as booking forms) from our shared systems and deleted much of this data, further impacting our ability to manage customer claims and finances.

I have several questions regarding possible legal actions and the relevant sections under Indian law to address this serious situation:

Grounds for Legal Action: What legal actions can I initiate in India for breach of contract, negligence in duties, potential fraud, and data theft, given that they failed to fulfill their contractual obligations to the UK company and are now absconding?

Relevant Sections and Acts: Under which specific sections of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) or civil contract law can I file a case? Are there specific provisions for:

Negligence in fulfilling back-office duties (including customer support and collections) that led to financial harm?
Absconding, fraud, and potential data theft, given their failure to transfer funds, safeguard critical data, or continue operations?
Breach of contract, as they did not fulfill their agreed responsibilities, including preserving essential customer data?
Process for Legal Action: Could you outline the process for filing a complaint or lawsuit against an absconding franchisee in Hyderabad, and what evidence will be crucial to support my case?

Possibility of Criminal Charges: Given the franchisee’s unresponsiveness, deletion of data, and the resulting financial impact, would this case qualify for criminal charges? If so, could charges like criminal breach of trust (Section 406), cheating (Section 420), or data theft apply under the IPC?

Recovery of Financial Damages: What options do I have to recover the financial losses and customer data that were compromised due to their negligence? Could the court order damages, restitution, or even require the retrieval of critical data if it can be located?

Steps for Immediate Action: Since the franchisee is absconding and has deleted data, is there any immediate legal action (such as sending a legal notice or filing a First Information Report (FIR)) you would recommend to formally initiate the case, protect my interests, and prevent further loss?

I would greatly appreciate any guidance you can provide on the above questions, as well as recommendations for the best course of action given the franchisee’s absconding status, deletion of data, and my priority to recover losses.

Thank you for your advice
Asked 25 days ago in Business Law

Ask a question and receive multiple answers in one hour.

Lawyers are available now to answer your questions.

4 Answers

You can file case for cheating ,criminal breach of trust against franchisee 

 

2)Section 43 of the IT Act

Civil liability in case of a computer database theft occurs when a computer trespass is committed, unauthorised digital copying is made, data is downloaded or extracted, privacy is violated, etc., under the Information Technology (Amendment) Act 2008.

 

3) Section 65 of the IT Act attracts the tampering of computer source documents in which the accused can be imprisoned for up to 3years or can be fined 2 lakh rupees or both.

 

4) you can also file civil suit for damages 

Ajay Sethi
Advocate, Mumbai
96917 Answers
7819 Consultations

 

  1. For breach of contractual terms you are entitled to compensation for loss or damage that arise due to such breach.
  2. If any penalty is stipulated in the contract for breach of terms, you are entitled to receive such penalty whether or not any loss suffered. You need to initiate above action in civil Court under Contract Act, Section 73 & 74.
  3. For failure to protect data, you are entitled to compensation under Section 43A if IT Act.
  4. If he is still suing your password, id you can file criminal complaint against him under Section 66B of IT. Punishment  for such offence is imprisonment  up to 3 years. Complaint under IT Act has to be filed in the  Court of VI Addl CMM Court, Hyderabad.
  5. You can file private complaint under Section 210 of B.N.S.S. 2023 depending on his location in the  Court of Magistrate  for cheating under Section 318 and for criminal breach of trust under Section 316 of BNS.
  6. If the franchise is P. Ltd. company, you can file complaint under Section 435 of Companies Act, 2013 in the Court for Economic Offences, at Nampally, Court complex, Hyderabad for offence of fraud under Section 447 if the  amount of fraud exceeds 10 Lakh rupees.
  7. Much depends on the terms of contract, if there is arbitration clause, it is safe to initiate criminal proceedings first, cos any criminal proceedings after invoking arbitration cause are likely to be quashed.
  8. All the above actions can be initiated from abroad through GPA 

Ravi Shinde
Advocate, Hyderabad
4195 Answers
42 Consultations

Section 43 of the Information Technology Act, 2000 deals with the civil liability for damage to computers and computer systems. It covers acts such as: 

Accessing, downloading, or introducing a computer virus without permission 

Causing denial of access 

Damaging a computer system 

Disrupting a computer system 

The penalty for these acts can be up to one crore rupees. 

Section 43 also states that if an act is done dishonestly and fraudulently, it may attract punishment under Section 66 of the Information Technology Act.

The Bombay High Court recently held that while the Information Technology Act, 2000 is a special Act for addressing cyber crimes and has an overriding effect, it does not preclude the application of IPC in cases where the offences are not adequately addressed under the IT Act.

Section 72 of the IT Act penalizes breaches of confidentiality and privacy, where access to electronic records or other material is obtained without the consent of the concerned person, resulting in disclosure to another party. On the other hand, IPC Sections 406, 408, and 409 pertain to criminal breach of trust by various categories of individuals, including public servants, clerks, or servants.

IPC Section 405 defines criminal breach of trust as dishonest misappropriation or conversion of entrusted property for personal use. IPC Section 403 defines dishonest misappropriation as the wrongful conversion of movable property.

If even one ingredient of an offence under the Indian Penal Code is missing in the act which has been made punishable under the special statute, the Indian Penal Code section will not be excluded and still can be resorted to albeit, the provisions of section 71 of the Indian Penal Code and section 26 of the General Clauses Act 

 

Therefore your options are to;

i) lodge a criminal complaint with the local police station where the suspect is believed to reside or was residing;

ii) You can ascertain the losses you suffered and can file a recovery suit  to recover the losses and damages through civil court too simultaneously 

iii) For breach of contract conditions you can file a civil suit for specific relief too.  The Specific Relief Act of 1963 in India allows a court to award compensation for a breach of contract if the court decides that specific performance is not enough to satisfy the case. The court will use the principles in the Indian Contract Act, 1872 to determine the amount of compensation. 

T Kalaiselvan
Advocate, Vellore
87118 Answers
2338 Consultations

- You can issue a legal notice to the said franchisee

- Further, if no response then lodge a complaint before the police and higher official , and can also file a complaint before the Judicial magistrate for lodging an FIR for the offence of cheating , breach of trust . 

Mohammed Shahzad
Advocate, Delhi
14495 Answers
221 Consultations

Ask a Lawyer

Get legal answers from lawyers in 1 hour. It's quick, easy, and anonymous!
  Ask a lawyer