1) penalty is exhorbitant
2) what is clause in your agreement regarding levy of penalty charges ?
3) reply to legal notice denying liability to pay Rs 25000
Hi, I had rented a bike from drivezy - a bike rental company. I rented the bike for 1 and half month. Rent per month was approximately 3000/- Due to certain unavoidable situation I returned the bike 12 days late. Now drivezy asking 14700/- penalty. I offered to rent the bike for next 5 months , pay 15000/- and not pay the penalty but they refused. I paid 2000/- I haven't paid rest 12700 yet since one year. They also send me a legal notice asking around 25000/- with in 15 days else they will do criminal and civil proceedings infant of competent court of law. What should I do?
1) penalty is exhorbitant
2) what is clause in your agreement regarding levy of penalty charges ?
3) reply to legal notice denying liability to pay Rs 25000
- Since you had taken the said bike @ 3000/- per month , and hence you are liable to pay only Rs. 1400/-for returning the bike 12 days late.
- Hence, the said demand of asking 14700/- is against the law and contract , specially if there is no written agreement entered by you with that company.
- You should stop to pay any amount to him , and further ask for refund the extra amount paid by you.
- You should reply the said legal notice and thereby ask to refund the extra paid amount by you .
- Legally no case is made out in the absence of any written contract .
Reply them by stating that they are asking the money illegally and you will file a complaint against them for extortion and harrassment
Wait and watch. Your reaction should be after their taking any action. Let them take any action as mentioned in their legal notice. In case they file suit for recovery in the court, you will receive summon alongwith copy of plaint and documents relied upon. Hire a local lawyer and file your written statement. At this stage, they would come for compromise. To me it seems to be a jackal threat. Relax. Take action when required.
The demand of App bike pool is not only unjustified but illegal as well.
Since didn't pay the extra amount forget the notice.
No case is going 3be filed as such expenses would be more than what is asked from you.
No criminal case can be initiated as well. The threshold empty one to say the least.
Dear sir,
1. Do not pay any further amount.
2. Reply to the legal notice stating the details you have mentioned above. Mention that the amount demanded by them is exorbitant and illegal, reasonable compensation for delay has already been paid and that you will not pay any additional charges whatsoever.
3. According to the legal principles, no criminal case is made out and you are liable to pay a compensation of approx Rs. 1500 only. Their legal team would be aware of this, and is unlikely to institute any proceedings.
4. Legal Notice is usually a last attempt to threaten and recover the amount. Do not worry!
Best wishes.
Reply to the legal notice through an advocate.
no need to pay any amount .
case is not maintainable .
Don't rwply to their legal notice. Instead send a legal notice stating that their conduct reflects deficiency in services and cheating and hence yu will file a complaint against them in the consumer forum in case they do anything rash.
Without going through the agreement it is difficult to say anything but would lije to request you to send them a reply duly drafted by a lawyer. The amount is exorbitant and a fit case of business malpractice for which you can sue them in a consumer court.
Definitely you have to reply the notice.
Can you Please discuss core issues of legal notice and its contents in detail to enable me to guide you for further and future course of action.
It is important that you send them a response to their legal notice. It is advisable that this reply is sent through a lawyer wherein you will have to meticulously oppose their exorbitant claim/penalty on account of the late handing over of bike. There’s a great possibility that post your reply, you and driveazy will be able to settle this amicably.
Have you read the terms and conditions if signed any document at the time of rental, if there is any clause of such penalty then you must pay otherwise reply the notice that they are only entitled for 12 days payment not any more if they file any case , they will file before the consumer forum where you can fight by paying much lesser amount as fees of the lawyer.
Dear Sir,
Calm down. First of all it is not a criminal case. Secondly for such small amount no advocate file a suit for recovery. Even if filed it will take years together. Get issue a fitting legal reply. Even then if the approach the Court by filing a suit you have get aware its procedure as follows. Be strong and fight personally. No advocate is necessary Courts are not running regularly in this Covid period. Discuss.
=================================================================
Procedure For Filing/Defending a Civil Suit/Case
There is a detailed procedure laid down, for filing a civil case. If the procedure is not followed, then the registry has a right to dismiss the suit
The Procedure is as follows:
Filing Of Suit/Plaint
Vakalatnama
Court Fees
How Proceedings Are Conducted
Written Statement
Replication By Plaintiff
Filing Of Other Documents
Framing Of Issues/List Of Witness
Final Hearing
Appeal, Reference And Review
Limitation
Filing of Suit/Plaint
Vakalatnama
Court Fees
Different amount of court fees is paid for different type of documents.
Finally, a date shall be given to the plaintiff, for first hearing. On such hearing, the court will decide whether the proceedings should continue or not. If it decides, that the case no merits, then it will dismiss it there itself, without calling opposite party. If it decides otherwise, then proceedings shall being
How Proceedings Are Conducted
Written Statement
Replication By Plaintiff
Filing of Other Documents
Framing of Issues/List of Witness
LIST OF WITNESS
Final Hearing
CERTIFIED COPY OF ORDER
Appeal, Reference and Review
When an order is passed against a party to the suit, it is not that it has no further remedy.
Such party can further initiate the proceedings, by way of:
In brief, the technicalities and difference between these are as follows:
APPEAL
APPEAL FROM ORIGINAL DECREES
(Sec.96)-
In general, an appeal lies from any decree passed by the court.
(Sec 96)
In cases, where the value of suit does not exceed Rs.xxx An appeal can be filed only on a question of law.
(Sec.96)
When a decree has been passed against the Defendant as "Ex-Parte", i.e. without his appearance, no appeal is allowed
(Sec.96)
When an appeal is headed by two or more judges, then the
majority decision shall prevail.
In case there is no majority, then the decree of lower court
shall be confirmed.
In case, the number of judges in the court, where appeal is filed is more, than the number of judges hearing the appeal, then if there is a dispute on a point of law, such dispute can be referred to one or more judges.
PROCEDURE FOR APPEAL FROM ORIGINAL DECREES ( ORDER 41)
Limitation
1. You have an positive option to file a grievance petition against the "drivezy", in the local Consumer Court, for their illegal trade practice, negligence, deficiency, harassment, intimidation, cheating etc.... with proper documentary evidences and you can claim damages /compensation & interest on your investment, and for your physical & mental trauma.
2. In the matter mentioned by you, "drivezy" CANNOT initiate any Criminal case on you, in any manner whatsoever.
Thank you for the replies. I am adding full details here so you can have a better understanding of my question. 1. Here is the Legal Notice: https://docs.google.com/document/d/13SH7AJQzUUr5GAR5W8DhyRe0Tb1UxSude8-xbI4fXmI/edit?usp=sharing [I have omitted the personal info] 2. Here is the relevant terms and condition of the Bike rental Company: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1C9i-uBMpVqM3dseoy2guqCcV14zDqvoUKIowaTOUo-4/edit?usp=sharing here is Company website page: https://drivezy.com/terms 3. I have deposited my Driving license with them ; I given a written note on a note book that I will pay them rest of the money by 3 months. I have put a signature. Really appreciate if you can go through them and give me a appropriate advice.
If you have given in writing that you will pay balance amount in 3 months you should make payment as agreed by you
My advice remains same. Only add criminal case under section 406 IPC as well .
I can only vet the said legal notice if you approach me separately for the same. For any assistance contact me in kaanoon on 9a7g6g9g4e9g0f9f1a1. Consultation applicable.
I have gone through the documents.
My answer still remains the same.
They are charging exorbitant amount and the same is impermissible according to law. The law states that the injured party can only claim reasonable damages. If they go to the court, the law will prevail over these terms and conditions.
If at all the situation arises, you defend putting your signatures by claiming that they were made to sign under duress in order to let you go.
Most probably they will not move to the court, if at all they do (rare possibility), you wont have to pay so much amount.
Do not worry.
- Legally they cannot keep your original driving licence for the said services.
- Further, the said declaration given by you for paying the amount is also not having any value , you can refuse the same .
- Lodge a complaint before the police for extortion of money against him and for keeping your licence.
If you have already assured and promised them that you will give them money then they will use that.
You may lodge a criminal complaint against them that they have taken your driving licence and are not returning it.
If they have sent you a legal notice then you issue a reply notice denying their allegations.
If there is no such clause in the agreement or if there is no agreement at all then you need not be worried about it.
Moreover demanding money through legal notice would not attract provisions of criminal law, hence if at all they intend to go to court they may have to file a civil case for recovery.
This being a meager amount they may not spend double the amount to recover this paltry amount.
You can demand the return of your DL held by them which is an illegal act, if they refuse to return then you may lodge a criminal complaint agaisnt them with the police for the extortion offences besides illegally retaining your DL.
You should reply to the notice that you are ready to pay rent for period for which the bike was kept by you after agreed term but will not pay penalty as it was not disclosed by your executive at time of delivery of bike.
The amount requested for is highly exorbitant and unreasonable. Reply to the legal notice. You should claim that neither you were shown the terms and conditions of the contract while booking neither you were verbally informed about the same. So such terms and conditions are not binding upon you. Also proceed to file a case under the consumer protection act claiming compensation for unfair trade practices by the company. They can't retain your license once bike is returned. Also seek direction from the court in an interim application to return your DL.
You may also claim that the note and signatures on the book were obtained under duress and they made you write saying that if you don't write we will cease destroy your license.
For a company like this you should go on the offensive. File a consumer case immediately and you may also file a criminal complaint against them for criminal breach of trust under section 405 IPC.