These cases are very common in various Courts of India and Supreme Court of India
You know Cost-to-Company is total money to be spend on engagement of such resource, during a year. As per section 3 of Payment of Wages Act, 1936, every employer shall be responsible for the payment of all wages reported to be paid under this Act to persons employed by him and in case of persons employed in Factories, Industrial or other establishments, etc. Please understand that CTC is never equal to the amount of take-home salary of the employee. There are many components in the CTC, where one does not receive all as part of take-home salary.
While dealing with such kind of cases in Supreme Court I have observed that CTC will be having the following components – which may be monetary or non-monetary.
• Monetary : Gross salary + Employer contribution of ESI + Employer contribution of PF + Bonus + Gratuity + LTA
• Non-monetary : House accommodation + Car + Driver + Servant + Club membership, etc
Gross salary will have the following components
• Basic salary + HRA & other Allowances + Reimbursements
Net or Take home salary
• Gross salary – Income Tax – Employer’s PF contribution – Employee’s ESI contribution – Professional Tax
Variable bonus can be included as one of the Head in the CTC to form part of a compensation.
Statutory bonus may not be included in the CTC, as it is on the Profit earned by the Establishment during the Financial Year and available surplus to compute the percentage to be disbursed. Few establishments are having 8.33% of Basic+DA as a component in CTC but if the available surplus is more than such percentage to be disbursed as Statutory Bonus, it will be challenging to book.
Gratuity is paid only in case of permanent disablement or death or separation after 5 years (or 4.240 years in some States of India). In such case including Gratuity as part of CTC structure is infructuous. Where such money is paid to a Gratuity Trust formed by the employer, it can be included in the CTC.
Paragraph 31 of the Employees’ Provident Funds Scheme, 1952 states that “Notwithstanding any contract to the contrary the employer shall not be entitled to deduct the employer’s contribution from the wage of a member or otherwise to recover it from him”.
To my mind many of the employer in today’s world give the breakup of outgoings under different heads as CTC in the appointment letter issued to a new employee. Emoluments means all earning by an employee for the work done by him in an establishment and includes Bonus, Commission, etc, whereas Basic Wages (as defined in the Act) expressly excludes these items / components. CTC cannot be therefore construed to mean ‘emoluments which are earned by an employee within the meaning of the term ‘basic wages’ as given under section 2 (b) of the Act and contribution under section 6 of the Act cannot be thus charged on CTC.
In India there is a principle law relating to this procedure of payment of bonus to the employees and that principle law is named as Payment of Bonus Act, 1965. Every employee not drawing salary/wages beyond Rs. 10,000 per month who has worked for not less than 30 days in an accounting year, shall be eligible for bonus for minimum of 8.33% of the salary/wages even if there is loss in the establishment whereas a maximum of 20% of the employee’s salary/wages is payable as bonus in an accounting year. However, in case of the employees whose salary/wages range between Rs. 3500 to Rs. 10,000 per month for the purpose of payment of bonus, their salaries/wages would be deemed to be Rs. 3500.
You may contact my secretary to connect with me for clarification.
I hope you and your family are safe and healthy. Stay home and be safe during Covid-19.
Gopal Verma,
Advocate on Record & Amicus Curiae,
Supreme Court of India