OBC reservation for Jats through notification dated 4th March 2014 has been quashed by SC on 17th March 2015. Any order can be prospective only and can not be retrospective. Therefore the results, admissions, appointments already done can not be set aside. Only in future i.e., from 17th March 2015 onwards subsequent to Supreme Court judgement, this order would be operative.
Jat OBC reservation cancelled by Supreme Court
dear sir As the jat obc notification dated 4th March 2014 has been quashed by Supreme Court on 17th March 2015 On its hearing on 9th April 2014 , interim prayer for stay was rejected by the Supreme Court ,however any action taken pursuant to the impunged notification subject to outcome of writ petitions was written . Hence obc quota was granted by government from 4th March onwards and all central universities , upsc consider jat as obc. Because there was no stay on it. What about the candidates who have got admission last year under the quota and Indian engineering services 2014 , Indian forestry services result declared and published availing quota. As at the time of application obc quota was there, and till the final result declared obc quota was there.
Asked 10 years ago in Civil Law
9 Answers
The students who got admission in jnu,du through jat as obc last year, qualified ugc net jrf exam June 2014 availing obc quota , any impact on them of the Supreme Court verdict
Asked 10 years ago
it is necessary to peruse detailed judgement passed by SC to advice .
if Sc has quashed job reservation based on caste ordinarily it would not affect candidates who got admission on basis of job quota as at that relevant period notification was in force
Sir these are the final words from judgement For the various reasons indicated above, we cannot agree with the view taken by the Union Government that Jats in the 9 (nine) States in question is a backward community so as to be entitled to inclusion in the Central Lists of Other Backward Classes for the States concerned. The view taken by the NCBC to the contrary is adequately supported by good and acceptable reasons which furnished a sound and reasonable basis for further consequential action on the part of the Union Government. In the above situation we cannot hold the notification dated 4.3.2014 to be justified. Accordingly the aforesaid notification bearing No. 63 dated 4.3.2014 including the Jats in the Central List of Other Backward Classes for the States of Bihar, Gujarat, Haryana, Himachal Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh, NCT of Delhi, Bharatpur and Dholpur Districts of Rajasthan, Uttar Pradesh and Uttarakhand is set aside and quashed. The writ petitions are accordingly allowed.
Asked 10 years ago
what does SC have to say in respect of those who got admission as per the said notification ? it must have dealt with the said issue also
1. The recruitments made under Jat OBC quota were valid and legal till the jat obc notification dated 4th March 2014 was rejected by the Apex Court,
2. From the date of the Order, there will be no further recruitment under Jat OBC quota.
Any further recruitment after the date of the Apex Cour order will be effected.
Who have already been effected before the date of the said rder will not be affected since the order is not with retrospective effect.
1. The judgement is "notification bearing No. 63 dated 4.3.2014 including the Jats in the Central List of Other Backward Classes for the States of Bihar, Gujarat, Haryana, Himachal Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh, NCT of Delhi, Bharatpur and Dholpur Districts of Rajasthan, Uttar Pradesh and Uttarakhand is set aside and quashed.",
2. The setting aside order is dated 17.3.2015,
3. It has been set aside from 17.3.2015 and before that the said order was very much in force.
The quashing of notification for OBC reservation by SC will be effective from the date of its judgement only and it can not be retrospective. It will not affect the results, admissions and appointments already finalised before [deleted]..
The apex court struck down the quota notification issued by the UPA government. this judgment will affect the politically significant Jats in Bihar, Gujarat, Haryana, Himachal Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh, Delhi, and Bharatpur and Dholpur districts of Rajasthan, Uttar Pradesh and Uttarakhand.
supreme court verdict is binding over every court and governments so unless government challenge it in review petition, jat reservation is now ceased to exist.
Will the cancellation of notification of jat quota would effect the results, admissions, appointments already done
Asked 10 years ago